
NEW YORK — Sotheby's said on Monday that the $180 million Van Gogh auction will go ahead as planned on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, despite a restitution claim from the heirs of the painting's former Jewish owner, who say it was sold under duress after the family fled Nazi Germany.
Van Gogh's "Chataigniers en fleurs" ("Blossoming Chestnut Trees"), painted in 1890, the year of the artist's death, carries the highest estimate of New York's autumn auction week. A sale near that figure would set a record price for a Van Gogh.
Sotheby's announced on Monday that the sale would proceed as planned, rejecting the argument that the restitution claim should halt the auction. The house said its research had not found evidence that the 1936 sale was forced, and pointed to the price achieved at the time as evidence the transaction was fair.
The claim comes from the heirs of Samuel Fischer, the German publisher who bought the painting in Paris in 1909. The family says the work was sold in Amsterdam in 1936 under duress, after the Fischers fled Nazi Germany. Their Berlin lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel, demands Sotheby's prove the painting sold at market value and that the family would have sold it even without Nazi rule.
"Blossoming Chestnut Trees" was painted in 1890, in the final months of Van Gogh's life. The canvas shows chestnut trees in full spring bloom, painted with the thick, swirling brushwork that became the artist's signature. Works of this quality rarely come to market.
The painting's modern history begins with Samuel Fischer, founder of one of Germany's great publishing houses, who bought it in Paris in 1909. The Fischer family fled Germany after the Nazis came to power, and the painting was sold in Amsterdam in 1936. The question is whether that sale was a free commercial decision or a forced sale under the pressure of persecution — the distinction that decides restitution claims under the principles agreed after the war.
Van Gogh's auction record stands at $117 million, set in 2022. A sale near the $180 million estimate would shatter that figure. The work is also backed by a guarantee from a third-party buyer.
The $180 million Van Gogh auction is remarkable for two opposite reasons. On one side, it is the art market at its most confident: a masterpiece by one of the world's most beloved painters, carrying the highest estimate of the season. On the other, it is a reminder that many great pictures in private hands passed through the hands of families fleeing persecution in the 1930s.
The price reflects how Van Gogh's market has grown — and how scarce top-tier Van Goghs have become. The artist produced around 900 paintings in a career of just ten years, and most of the best are already in museums, where they will never be sold.
The painting is the centrepiece of the Blaquier-Arrieta collection, expected to fetch $450 million in total, in a New York auction week worth more than $2 billion. The dispute over its star painting casts a shadow over the whole offering.
Sotheby's does not accept the heirs' account of the 1936 sale. The house said its research "has not established that the painting was sold under duress", citing archives showing the work sold for 68,000 Swiss francs in June 1936, a price it described as strong for the time: a fair price, the argument runs, points to a free sale.
The heirs' lawyer, Gunnar Schnabel of Berlin, demands Sotheby's prove the painting sold at market value and that the Fischer family would have sold it even without Nazi rule. It is not enough, in the family's view, to show that a price was paid: the house must show the sale would have happened anyway.
The case tests how the art market handles the legacy of the Nazi era, ninety years on. Thousands of works changed hands in Europe in the 1930s and 1940s under pressure of persecution, and many are now worth tens or hundreds of millions of dollars. Each public claim forces the market to decide how much history a buyer must know — and how much a seller must prove.
It also matters because of the money. A $180 million sale would be the biggest Van Gogh result ever. If the dispute spooks bidders, the guarantee protects Sotheby's, but a soft result would signal that provenance problems carry a price.
The auction is scheduled for Wednesday, November 18, 2026, at Sotheby's in New York. Barring a court order or a last-minute settlement, "Blossoming Chestnut Trees" will be offered with its $180 million estimate and its guarantee in place.
Attention will then turn to what the heirs do next. If the painting sells, they may pursue a claim against the proceeds or the buyer, or keep pressing Sotheby's for a settlement. If it fails to sell, the dispute will hang over any future sale.
How much is the Van Gogh painting expected to sell for?
The painting carries a $180 million estimate from Sotheby's, the highest of New York's autumn auction week. Van Gogh's previous auction record was $117 million, set in 2022.
Why are the heirs claiming the painting?
The heirs of publisher Samuel Fischer, who bought it in Paris in 1909, say it was sold under duress in Amsterdam in 1936 after the family fled Nazi Germany.
What does Sotheby's say about the claim?
Sotheby's says its research "has not established that the painting was sold under duress", citing archives showing it sold for 68,000 Swiss francs, about $22,000, in June 1936 — a strong price at the time.
When is the auction, and could it still be stopped?
The auction is set for Wednesday, November 18, 2026, in New York. Unless a court orders otherwise or a settlement is reached, Sotheby's says the sale will proceed.
Related coverage: Kobe Bryant's high school jersey sells for a record $2.2 million at Sotheby's, Robert Pattinson is the new James Bond, and Savannah Guthrie renews her NBC contract to stay on Today.