
Outgoing Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton has dropped his lawsuit accusing the NCAA of misleading college sports fans by allowing transgender athletes to compete in events marketed as women's competitions, closing a flashpoint case in the national fight over women's sports.
Paxton's office told a Lubbock court on Thursday, November 12, that it would not proceed with the claims, abandoning them without prejudice; Bloomberg Law first reported the decision on November 13. The move came nine days after Paxton lost his bid for the United States Senate on November 3, and weeks before his successor takes office.
Paxton's office filed a notice with the state district court in Lubbock saying it would abandon the case, ending nearly two years of litigation that never reached a ruling on the merits. Because the claims were dropped without prejudice, they could in theory be brought again, but there is no sign that will happen: the NCAA has already adopted the policy Paxton was demanding, and a new attorney general is about to take over the office that filed the case. Neither Paxton's office nor the NCAA immediately responded to requests for comment.
Paxton filed the NCAA lawsuit in December 2024, arguing that the association was deceiving Texas sports fans. The complaint said the NCAA marketed its competitions as women's athletics while permitting athletes it described as biological males to compete against biological females, and it asked the court either to bar transgender athletes from women's events in Texas or to stop the NCAA from marketing those events as women's sports.
The case was one of the most prominent in a wave of state lawsuits over transgender participation in sports. Trump signed an executive order in 2025 aimed at keeping transgender women out of women's sports, and the NCAA responded by changing its own policy to ban transgender women from women's competitions. That change removed much of the practical force from Paxton's case, since the NCAA was already doing what the lawsuit asked for.
The decision to drop it also reflects Paxton's changed political position. He lost the November 3 Senate race to Democrat James Talarico, and in the same election Democrat Nathan Johnson defeated Republican Mayes Middleton to become the next Texas attorney general, the first Democrat to hold the office since 1994.
At the heart of the Ken Paxton NCAA lawsuit was a consumer-protection argument, not a direct challenge to the NCAA's right to set its own rules. Paxton's 57-page complaint, filed under the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act, said fans buying tickets to events billed as women's competitions were being misled. The suit claimed the NCAA was "intentionally and knowingly jeopardizing the safety and wellbeing of women" by allowing transgender athletes to take part.
Paxton sought a permanent injunction barring transgender athletes from women's events in Texas, or involving Texas teams, and an order stopping the NCAA from marketing such events as women's sports unless it excluded them. The case drew support from critics of transgender participation in women's sports and sharp criticism from LGBTQ advocates, who said it targeted a tiny number of athletes. Legal observers had called the consumer-fraud theory a novel stretch, and once the NCAA adopted the ban, the case's central demand was effectively met.
Paxton framed the case in stark terms when he filed it in 2024, saying the NCAA was "intentionally and knowingly jeopardizing the safety and wellbeing of women" by letting transgender athletes compete in women's events. His office has not explained its decision to walk away from the case now. The NCAA also did not immediately comment, though the association has previously defended its 2025 policy change as a response to the federal executive order and to the need for clear, consistent eligibility rules across college sports.
The incoming attorney general, Nathan Johnson, has signalled a broader review of the lawsuits Paxton filed. "Everything will be examined," Johnson said after his election victory, adding that he would halt cases he considered political rather than grounded in the law.
The end of the case marks a quiet turning point in one of the most heated culture-war fights in American sports. For two years, the lawsuit was a symbol of Texas's aggressive use of its attorney general's office to challenge national institutions over transgender rights. Its abandonment, without a court ruling and without a fight, shows how quickly that posture is changing with the office about to change hands.
It also matters because the NCAA's 2025 policy change already settled the practical question at the centre of the case: transgender women are barred from women's competitions under the association's current rules, so the lawsuit's main demand is now the NCAA's own policy.
Johnson will take office in January and has said his review of Paxton-era lawsuits will begin quickly. The NCAA case is already closed, but other pending cases, including Texas's challenges over abortion medication and immigration enforcement, will be examined under the same standard he has described.
The NCAA's ban on transgender women in women's sports remains in place and is not affected by the dismissal. Any future legal challenge to that policy would more likely come from athletes or advocacy groups arguing the ban itself is unlawful, rather than from a state demanding it.
Why did Ken Paxton drop the NCAA lawsuit?
Paxton's office gave no reason. The NCAA had already banned transgender women from women's sports in 2025, meeting the lawsuit's main demand, and Paxton lost his Senate race on November 3.
What did the lawsuit claim?
It said the NCAA violated the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act by marketing events as women's athletics while allowing transgender athletes to compete.
Can the case be brought back?
The claims were dropped without prejudice, so they could technically be refiled, but a revival looks unlikely with the NCAA's ban in place.
Who is the next Texas attorney general?
Democrat Nathan Johnson, who beat Republican Mayes Middleton on November 3 and has pledged to review Paxton-era lawsuits.
Does the dismissal change the NCAA's rules?
No. The NCAA's 2025 ban on transgender women in women's sports remains in effect.
Read more on US News Pulse: Democratic attorney general wins in five states could reshape US lawsuits, NCAA eligibility ruling: appeals court hands NCAA its biggest win yet and Elon Musk deletes 'Vote red today' post after Democrats sweep 2026 midterms.