
The United States Senate voted 51-46 on Monday to confirm Judge Daniel Domenico to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals, handing President Donald Trump another lifetime appointment to a federal appeals court as Republicans race to fill judicial vacancies before Democrats take control of the chamber in January. The vote, recorded as roll-call vote 263, elevated the Colorado district judge to the Denver-based court in a party-line fight that showed how much is at stake in the final weeks of Republican control.
Domenico, appointed to the federal bench in Colorado during Trump's first term, will succeed Circuit Judge Timothy Tymkovich. His confirmation came on the same day the Senate advanced a major permitting bill, and it opened what Republicans hope will be a rapid run of judicial confirmations before the new Congress is seated.
Senators voted 51-46 on Monday to confirm Domenico, with the narrow margin reflecting the chamber's tight partisan split in the lame-duck session. The vote came in the same session in which lawmakers voted 70-27 to advance a bipartisan permitting bill, a reminder of how much unfinished business is packed into the final weeks of the current Congress.
Domenico's nomination had been scheduled for a Monday vote for days, and its confirmation was widely expected once it reached the floor. What made the vote significant was not surprise but timing: every appeals-court seat filled now is a seat Democrats cannot fill after January, and Republicans have made judicial confirmations a central mission of the lame-duck period.
Domenico has served as a U.S. district judge in Colorado since his appointment by President Trump during the president's first term. His elevation to the Tenth Circuit moves him from the trial bench to one of the country's 13 federal appeals courts, where panels of three judges decide cases that can only be reviewed further by the Supreme Court.
The Tenth Circuit is based in Denver and covers a vast stretch of the American West and Great Plains, taking appeals from federal district courts in Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming. Its docket spans energy and public-lands disputes, immigration cases, Native American tribal issues, criminal appeals and challenges to federal agency action, giving its judges an outsized role in the law of the region.
The court's 7-5 split in favour of Democratic appointees is one reason the confirmation drew close attention. A single seat does not flip the court's majority, but appeals-court majorities are built one confirmation at a time, and the ideological balance of a circuit shapes the law for millions of people across six states for decades, because federal judges serve for life.
For the White House, Domenico's confirmation is also a proof of concept for the broader lame-duck strategy: confirm as many of the 22 pending judicial picks as possible before the calendar runs out.
Senate Republican leaders have made no secret of the urgency, describing judicial confirmations as a top priority for the remainder of the session and pressing to move nominees while the majority still holds the floor schedule. The White House has said it expects all judicial nominees pending in the Senate to be confirmed this year, a goal that would require an unusually fast pace in the weeks ahead.
Democrats, who take control of both chambers in January, have little procedural ability to block individual confirmations in the current Senate, where a simple majority is enough. Their leverage comes with the calendar: every nominee not confirmed by the time the new Congress is seated will have to be renominated.
Federal appeals courts are, for most Americans, the last word in the law. The Supreme Court hears only a tiny fraction of cases, so the judges of the Tenth Circuit effectively decide the outcome of disputes over public lands, energy development, immigration enforcement and federal regulation across six states.
Domenico's lifetime appointment means his influence on that law will extend for decades, long after the politics of the lame-duck session have faded. That durability is precisely why both parties treat judicial confirmations as legacy-defining work, and why the final weeks of an outgoing majority are often the most productive period for confirmations.
The Senate is expected to hold a final confirmation vote this week for U.S. District Judge Anna St. John of the Eastern District of Louisiana, nominated to the New Orleans-based Fifth Circuit. A procedural vote last Thursday teed up that confirmation, and it is next in line after Domenico.
Beyond St. John, the White House's list of 22 other pending judicial picks will compete for floor time against the permitting bill's final votes and the year-end spending measures Congress must pass before the current session ends. Any nominee not confirmed by the time the new Congress is seated in January will be returned to the White House, and renomination would face a Democratic-controlled Senate.
Daniel Domenico is a U.S. district judge in Colorado, appointed to the federal bench by President Donald Trump during his first term. The Senate confirmed him on November 16, 2026, to serve on the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals.
The Senate confirmed Domenico by a vote of 51-46, recorded as roll-call vote 263, in a largely party-line vote during the lame-duck session.
The Denver-based Tenth Circuit hears appeals from Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah and Wyoming. Judges appointed by Democratic presidents currently hold a 7-5 majority among the court's active judges.
U.S. District Judge Anna St. John of the Eastern District of Louisiana, nominated to the Fifth Circuit, is next in line, with a final confirmation vote expected this week after a procedural vote last Thursday.
Democrats take control of the Senate in January after the November 3 midterm elections, so Republicans are using the final weeks of their majority to confirm as many of the 22 pending judicial nominees as possible before the window closes.
Related coverage: the Senate's other major vote in the same session, advancing the bipartisan permitting bill by 70-27, and the Republican resistance that has slowed some of Trump's judicial nominees in the lame-duck push.