
The United States Senate voted 52-46 on Tuesday to confirm Anna St. John to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, giving President Donald Trump his second appellate-court victory in two days as the Republican majority races to fill the federal bench before Democrats take control of Congress in January.
St. John has served about six months as a federal district judge in Louisiana. She will now take a lifetime seat on the New Orleans-based appeals court, one of the most influential in the country, as the Senate's lame-duck session counts down its final weeks.
Senate Republicans have made the remaining judicial confirmations their top priority. With Democrats set to take both chambers on January 3, 2027, after sweeping the November 3 midterm elections, the majority is working through as many of President Trump's 21 remaining judicial nominees as it can.
The Senate confirmed St. John on a 52-46 vote, with Republicans supplying the votes needed to carry the nomination through the chamber they still control. The vote was one of several judicial confirmations expected during the lame-duck session, as the majority moves quickly through its backlog of nominees.
On the same day, the Senate Judiciary Committee advanced three more district-court nominees — Robert Long, Peter Mansfield and Jesus Osete. The committee put off votes on two Oklahoma district nominees, including Zach West, amid a standoff; their path may open on November 30, when Senator-elect Kevin Hern succeeds Armstrong.
Anna St. John came to the federal bench only this year. She was confirmed to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana on March 17, 2026, and has served on that court for about half a year. Her swift elevation makes her one of the fastest-rising judges of the Trump era.
Before joining the bench, St. John was president and general counsel of the Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute, a nonprofit public-interest law firm. There she worked on cases involving religious liberty, free speech and the rights of women in sports — the record President Trump praised when he nominated her to the Fifth Circuit.
The Fifth Circuit, based in New Orleans, hears federal appeals from Louisiana, Texas and Mississippi. It is one of the most closely watched appeals courts in the country, known for routinely delivering victories to conservative litigants in cases involving immigration, energy regulation, abortion, gun rights and federal agency power.
St. John fills the seat left by Judge Kurt Engelhardt, appointed by President Trump during his first term and now on senior status, a form of semi-retirement that opens the seat for a new judge. Her arrival comes as the court sits at the centre of several of the most consequential legal fights in the country, deciding cases on border enforcement, energy production and business regulation.
The White House has framed the confirmation as part of a broader push to remake the federal judiciary before the new Congress takes office. The administration is pressing to clear 22 other pending judicial nominations in the final weeks of Republican control, and Trump has praised St. John's record championing religious liberty, free speech and protecting women's sports.
Democrats, who will hold the Senate majority from January, have opposed the pace of the lame-duck confirmations. They argue the outgoing majority is rushing lifetime appointments through in its final weeks, after voters in the November 3 midterms handed control of Congress to the other party.
Federal judges serve for life, and every confirmation in this lame-duck session locks in a judicial voice that will shape American law for decades. Trump has now confirmed 56 judges in his second term, on top of 234 in his first term, and each new appeals-court judge extends that imprint.
The stakes are especially high on the Fifth Circuit. Because the court covers Texas and Louisiana, it hears challenges to federal energy rules, immigration enforcement and abortion restrictions that affect the whole country — and from January 3, Democrats will control the Senate, with Senator Sheldon Whitehouse set to chair the Judiciary Committee. Every seat filled now is a seat the new majority cannot block.
St. John will now take her seat on the Fifth Circuit, leaving a vacancy on the district court in Louisiana that the administration will need to fill. Her elevation also means the Eastern District of Louisiana loses a judge after only about six months.
The Senate is expected to keep voting on judicial nominees in the coming days, and the standoff over the two Oklahoma district nominees, including Zach West, may resolve on November 30, when Senator-elect Kevin Hern takes his seat. Until then, the focus stays on the appellate confirmations — and on whether the majority can clear the rest of Trump's 21 remaining judicial picks before Democrats take the gavel in January.
Who is Anna St. John?
Anna St. John is a federal judge who served about six months as a U.S. District Judge for the Eastern District of Louisiana before the Senate confirmed her to the Fifth Circuit on November 17, 2026. She was previously president and general counsel of the Hamilton Lincoln Law Institute.
What is the Fifth Circuit?
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit is the federal appeals court covering Louisiana, Texas and Mississippi. Based in New Orleans, it is known for rulings that frequently favour conservative litigants in cases on immigration, energy, abortion and federal regulatory power.
How did the Senate vote?
The Senate confirmed St. John by 52-46 on Tuesday, November 17, 2026, in a party-line vote in the Republican-controlled chamber. It was the second Trump appellate confirmation in two days, after Judge Daniel Domenico's 51-46 confirmation to the Tenth Circuit on Monday.
Why is the confirmation happening now?
Senate Republicans are racing to confirm as many of President Trump's remaining judicial nominees as possible before Democrats take control of both chambers on January 3, 2027, after their sweep of the November 3 midterm elections.
What happens to her district court seat?
St. John's move to the Fifth Circuit leaves a vacancy on the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Louisiana, which the administration will need to fill with a new nominee.
Related coverage: Senate Confirms Daniel Domenico to Tenth Circuit 51-46 in Lame-Duck Push; Trump Urges Senate to Confirm 161 Nominations Before Democrats Take Over; Democrats' Senate Wins Cripple Trump's Push to Reshape the Courts.