
The U.S. Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas in its criminal investigation into the Alaska Senate candidate known as "Decoy Dan," Fox News Digital reported exclusively on Wednesday, November 18, 2026. The subpoenas mark the latest escalation in an inquiry into whether Democratic operatives recruited retired teacher Dan J. Sullivan to run for the Senate and confuse voters who meant to support the Republican incumbent, Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. Two law enforcement sources confirmed the count, and investigators say the election result changes nothing about the case.
Fox News Digital first reported the subpoena total on Wednesday, citing a law enforcement source, with a second source confirming the count. The probe now reaches across multiple states and involves more than one criminal target, though the Justice Department has not named any of them. The subpoenas demand records, communications and testimony from people and organisations connected to the second Sullivan's candidacy.
The count stood at more than 40 subpoenas in late October, rose past 100 and then 120 in early November, and has now passed 200. Alaska U.S. Attorney Michael Heyman said on October 30 that investigators had been working the case for months.
The allegation is that Democratic operatives recruited a candidate named Dan Sullivan to confuse voters and draw support from the Republican incumbent. The incumbent is a two-term senator; "Decoy Dan" is Dan J. Sullivan, a retired teacher from Petersburg, Alaska. Peltola's campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee deny any involvement in recruiting him.
Peltola won with 144,302 votes to the incumbent Sullivan's 131,844, a margin of 12,458. "Decoy Dan" received 4,760 votes — fewer than a third of the winning margin, so his votes alone could not have changed the outcome even if every one had gone to the incumbent. The result gave Democrats a 56-44 Senate majority, and the Associated Press called the race on Tuesday, November 17.
The subpoena count tells the story of an investigation that has widened steadily since it became public. In late October, when the probe first surfaced, the Justice Department had issued more than 40 subpoenas. By early November that figure had climbed past 100 and then 120, and the latest count of more than 200 shows investigators are still pulling in new material weeks after the election.
The most striking development was the criminal target letter sent earlier in November to Marc Elias, the high-profile Democratic election lawyer whose firm represents Peltola's campaign. A target letter warns that prosecutors believe a person may have committed a crime; it does not mean charges will follow. Elias has not been charged, and the Justice Department, led by Attorney General Todd Blanche, has not named its targets.
A law enforcement source told Fox News Digital that the election result has not slowed the investigation. "Peltola being named the winner doesn't change anything from an investigative standpoint," the source said. The probe is about how the second Sullivan's candidacy came about, not about who won the seat.
Peltola's campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee deny any role in recruiting the second Sullivan, and no charges have been announced. Republican Gov. Mike Dunleavy has said a state criminal investigation is also running alongside the federal probe. State election officials plan to certify the results on November 25, as required by law.
The case tests where aggressive campaign tactics cross into criminal conduct. Recruiting a candidate with the same name as an opponent is an old political trick, but federal investigators are treating this as a possible conspiracy, not a stunt. The involvement of a lawyer of Elias's standing — he has represented Democratic campaigns in election litigation for years — raises the stakes further.
It also matters for Alaska. Peltola's victory flipped a Senate seat and helped deliver Democrats their 56-44 majority, and the new Congress takes office on January 3, 2027. A criminal case touching the campaign that won the seat would hang over the start of her term, even though the vote margin shows the decoy candidate could not have decided the race.
The results are scheduled for certification on November 25. Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher has said she plans to certify the election as required by law, including Peltola's Senate victory. Certification would make the result official and close the door on challenges to the count itself.
The investigation has no timetable. Prosecutors will work through the material gathered by more than 200 subpoenas, and the next public sign of progress would be charges — or a decision that none are warranted. The state investigation announced by Dunleavy will run in parallel.
What is the "Decoy Dan" probe?
It is a Justice Department criminal investigation into Dan J. Sullivan, a retired Petersburg teacher who ran in Alaska's 2026 Senate race under the same name as Republican incumbent Sen. Dan S. Sullivan. Investigators are examining whether Democratic operatives recruited him to confuse voters.
How many subpoenas has the Justice Department issued?
More than 200, Fox News Digital reported on November 18, 2026, citing two law enforcement sources. The count grew from more than 40 in late October to more than 120 in early November.
Did Mary Peltola's victory end the investigation?
No. A law enforcement source said Peltola being named the winner "doesn't change anything from an investigative standpoint." The probe continues.
Who is Marc Elias and why did he receive a target letter?
Elias is a prominent Democratic election lawyer whose firm represents Peltola's campaign. He received a criminal target letter earlier in November, a formal warning that prosecutors believe he may have committed a crime. He has not been charged.
When will Alaska certify the election results?
State certification is scheduled for November 25, 2026. Division of Elections Director Carol Beecher has said she plans to certify as required by law.
Read our earlier report on Mary Peltola winning Alaska's Senate seat as Democrats clinched a 56-44 majority and Republican Nick Begich winning reelection to Alaska's lone U.S. House seat.