
The Trump administration moved on Thursday to drop its lawsuit challenging Democrat Mary Peltola's victory in Alaska's U.S. Senate race, asking a federal appeals court to declare the case moot and end a much-criticised legal gambit aimed at blocking certification of one of the biggest upsets of the 2026 midterms. The Justice Department filing to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals came two days after the race was decided, with Peltola winning an outright majority to become the Democrats' 56th senator and their ninth Senate pickup in a midterm blowout that flipped control of Congress.
Justice Department lawyers asked the 9th Circuit to undo the lower court's dismissal of the case in order to erase the loss, and then dismiss the case anyway. In their filing, they said the court "should hold that this case is moot, vacate the underlying order, and remand for dismissal on that ground." The move effectively ends the administration's bid to stop Alaska from certifying Peltola's victory. The legal challenge centred on the presence on the ballot of a second candidate with the same name as the incumbent, Republican Senator Dan Sullivan. The administration argued that a Peltola win should not be certified until an investigation could determine whether voters had been confused. The Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled that the second Sullivan's candidacy was legal and that he could appear on the ballot. Alaska's own attorneys, representing a Republican-controlled state government, had called the challenge legally "meritless" and filed papers seeking dismissal of the original case.
The Justice Department filed the lawsuit before Election Day at President Donald Trump's direction. Trump had spent weeks attacking the race, calling the second Sullivan a "fake Dan Sullivan" and demanding that his votes be handed to the Republican incumbent. The case was filed before The New York Times reported on texts and other documents that appeared to show Peltola's campaign was involved in recruiting the retired schoolteacher from the tiny fishing community of Petersburg. He was listed on the ballot as Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., with no party preference, to distinguish him from the senator, who was identified as a Republican and the incumbent. Dan J. Sullivan has long insisted he ran on his own, and Peltola has denied any involvement. Peltola went on to win the race outright, taking 50.1 percent once ranked-choice tabulation was complete. Judge Sharon Gleason had dismissed the lawsuit on Sunday, November 1, ruling that the relief it sought was infeasible, and the department appealed hours later. Peltola's campaign had also sued Alaska for records on rejected absentee ballots. A judge later denied that request, and the count proceeded to its conclusion.
Peltola welcomed the filing and said it was time to move on. "Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I'm eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans," she said in a statement. The retreat drew attention because the administration had made the Alaska race a showcase of its claims about the election, with Trump repeatedly insisting the contest had been stolen. Federal investigators are still pursuing a separate strand of the affair: the Justice Department has issued 200 subpoenas in its "Decoy Dan" probe, a criminal investigation that continues even as the civil lawsuit is abandoned.
The decision removes the last legal cloud over one of the most consequential results of the midterms. Peltola's win gave Democrats their 56th Senate seat and their ninth pickup of the night, sealing a 56-44 majority that will take control of the chamber in January. Had the challenge succeeded, it would have thrown Alaska's certification into doubt and delayed the seating of a senator the voters chose by a clear majority. The retreat also fits a wider pattern. Just days after the election, the Justice Department moved to drop a lawsuit seeking to prevent California officials from counting roughly 20,000 ballots. The administration alleged the ballots belonged to suspected noncitizens, but election officials questioned the data and said the government's list contained many U.S. citizens. Together, the two withdrawals suggest the department is quietly stepping back from its most aggressive post-election lawsuits.
The 9th Circuit is now expected to grant the administration's request, declare the case moot, vacate Judge Gleason's dismissal and send the matter back to be dismissed. Alaska will certify all of its election results on November 25, as planned, and Peltola will take her seat when the new Congress convenes in January. The criminal side of the story is not over: the Justice Department's "Decoy Dan" investigation, with its 200 subpoenas, continues, and Trump's demand that Peltola be prosecuted has not been withdrawn. But the civil lawsuit that sought to block certification is finished, and with it one of the most closely watched legal fights of the 2026 election.
What did the Trump administration ask the court to do? It asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to declare its Alaska Senate lawsuit moot, vacate the lower court's dismissal and remand the case for dismissal, effectively dropping the challenge to Mary Peltola's win.
Why was the lawsuit filed? The Justice Department, acting at President Donald Trump's direction, argued a Peltola win should not be certified until an investigation into possible voter confusion caused by a second candidate on the ballot named Dan J. Sullivan.
Who is the second Dan Sullivan? Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., a retired schoolteacher from Petersburg, Alaska, who appeared on the ballot with no party preference. The Alaska Supreme Court ruled his candidacy legal. He took 4,760 votes, about 1.6 percent, fewer than Peltola's margin of victory.
What was the final result in Alaska? Peltola won 50.1 percent of the vote, 144,302 votes to 131,844 for Republican Senator Dan Sullivan, a lead of more than 12,000, making her the Democrats' 56th senator.
What happens next? The 9th Circuit is expected to declare the case moot and dismiss it. Alaska will certify its results on November 25, and Peltola will take her seat when the new Congress convenes in January.