
UNIVERSITY PARK, Pennsylvania — Rutgers stunned Penn State 25-24 on Saturday at Beaver Stadium, scoring a touchdown on a lateral with no time left and converting a two-point try to end a 38-year wait for a win over the Nittany Lions. The Rutgers Penn State finish was one of the wildest endings of the college football season, turning a 25.5-point underdog into the author of a famous upset.
Rutgers trailed 24-10 early in the fourth quarter before scoring 15 points in the final 10 minutes and 19 seconds. The Scarlet Knights had lost four straight games by a combined 87 points and had not beaten Penn State since 1988.
Penn State controlled most of the game. The Nittany Lions led 16-0 in the first half and stretched the advantage to 24-10 early in the fourth quarter, after Becht scored on a keeper and then caught a two-point conversion with 4:57 left in the third quarter.
Rutgers began its comeback with 10:19 left, when Raymond scored from 13 yards to make it 24-17. The defence held, and the offence got one last chance. With six seconds on the clock, Surace threw short to Raymond near the goal line. Raymond was being tackled as he reached for the end zone, but he pitched the ball to Black, who ran the final three yards in as time expired.
The touchdown tied the game at 24-24, and Schiano faced the decision that defines coaches: kick the extra point and take overtime, or go for two and the win. He went for the win. Surace kept the ball and scored the two-point conversion, giving Rutgers a 25-24 lead. The Scarlet Knights improved to 3-8 overall and 2-6 in the Big Ten, while Penn State fell to 6-5 and 3-5.
Rutgers had not beaten Penn State since 1988, when it won 21-16 at Beaver Stadium against a Nittany Lions side ranked No. 15 in the country. Since then, Penn State had won 18 straight meetings, a streak spanning Rutgers’ move into the Big Ten in 2014 and every season since.
The gap between the programmes has been the story of the series. Penn State has played for Big Ten titles and New Year’s Six bowl games, while Rutgers has spent much of its Big Ten life near the bottom of the standings. The Scarlet Knights arrived in University Park at 3-8, already out of bowl contention, while Penn State, at 6-5, was already bowl eligible but well short of expectations.
The final play will be replayed for years in New Jersey. Surace’s pass to Raymond was short, and Raymond was wrapped up just short of the goal line. As he was going down, he flipped the ball to Black, who had trailed the play and found a clear path to the end zone. Three yards later, the clock read zero and the game was tied.
Laterals on the final play are among the rarest sights in football, because they require awareness, timing and luck in equal measure. Raymond had the awareness to keep the ball alive and the composure to find a team-mate rather than go down. The two-point conversion was almost as bold: Schiano could have kicked for overtime, where Penn State would have been favourite, but he trusted Surace to win it on one play, and the quarterback delivered.
Schiano’s decision to go for two summed up the afternoon. A team with nothing to lose played like it, and the coach’s call matched the mood of his players, who had fought back from 16 points down and believed they could finish the job.
For Raymond, the game was a personal statement. His 101 rushing yards and two touchdowns carried the offence, and his heads-up pitch made the upset possible. Penn State was left to explain how a 14-point fourth-quarter lead became a one-point defeat, despite Becht’s 233 passing yards.
For Rutgers, the win changes the feel of a difficult season. A 3-8 team with four straight heavy defeats had little left to play for except pride, and it found a result that will be talked about in New Jersey for years: a first win over Penn State since 1988, in Beaver Stadium.
For Penn State, the defeat is a bitter one. Losing at home to a 25.5-point underdog, in the final home game of the season, after leading by 14 in the fourth quarter, is the sort of result that lingers. The Nittany Lions are bowl eligible at 6-5, but the season will now be remembered in part for the afternoon Rutgers stole a game in the final seconds.
Both teams play their season finales next week. Rutgers, at 3-8, cannot reach a bowl game, but it will carry the momentum of the upset into the final game and the off-season. Penn State, at 6-5, will go to a bowl game, but must first regroup from a defeat that will sting.
Rutgers won 25-24 at Beaver Stadium on Saturday, Nov. 21, 2026, scoring a touchdown on a lateral as time expired and then converting a two-point try.
Surace threw short to Antwan Raymond, who was being tackled near the goal line and lateraled to Ben Black III, who ran the final three yards in as time expired.
Surace scored it himself after coach Greg Schiano decided to go for the win instead of kicking the tying extra point and taking the game to overtime.
In 1988, when Rutgers won 21-16 at Beaver Stadium against a Penn State side ranked No. 15. Penn State had won the next 18 meetings.
Rutgers is 3-8 overall and 2-6 in the Big Ten. Penn State is 6-5 overall and 3-5 in the Big Ten, and is already bowl eligible.
Related coverage: Washington stuns No. 8 Indiana 27-24 in overtime to shake up playoff race and Michigan beats Rutgers 28-21 as Tommy Carr’s late touchdown seals road win.