
New York City has ordered the controlled demolition of the three-storey building at 1323 Flatbush Avenue in Brooklyn, beside the site of the deadly November 11 collapse that killed eight people. Forensic engineers found the building too unstable for workers to enter safely and shore it up, leaving demolition as the only option, Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani said.
The order, issued under an Immediate Emergency Declaration and reported on Wednesday, November 18, is the latest grim turn in the tragedy. The building lost its adjoining wall when 1321 Flatbush Avenue collapsed into an excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue, and it has kept deteriorating ever since, its interior exposed to the weather.
Key Points
The building at 1323 Flatbush Avenue was wounded the moment its neighbour fell. When 1321 Flatbush collapsed into the excavation at 2625 Bedford Avenue on Wednesday, November 11, it tore away the adjoining wall of 1323 Flatbush, leaving rooms open to the sky. Eight people were killed, including two children, and 18 more were injured.
In the days that followed, the damaged building kept deteriorating. Its interior, exposed to rain and wind, weakened further, and engineers concluded no worker could safely go inside to shore it up. The Department of Buildings then issued an Immediate Emergency Declaration for the demolition and fenced off a collapse zone around the site. Before demolition begins, the agency will install shoring at 1325 Flatbush Avenue.
For the tenants, the order closes the door on going home. They cannot re-enter to retrieve belongings, both because the structure could give way and because the building is heavily contaminated with asbestos. Vacate orders at 1325 and 1327 Flatbush Avenue remain in effect.
The collapse on November 11 was one of the deadliest building failures in New York in years. The 96-year-old building at 1321 Flatbush Avenue fell into an excavation for a new development at 2625 Bedford Avenue, burying residents. Firefighters searched the rubble for days, and eight victims were named, among them 31-year-old Ndiaye Mamadou and two child cousins, aged 9 and 10. Our earlier report on the collapse and the search of the rubble covered the first hours.
Questions about the project next door followed immediately. The city had signed off in March 2026 on a three-storey, eight-unit project at 2625 Bedford Avenue, but filings showed the developer intended an unapproved nine-storey building with 64 apartments. Our report on the developer's nine-storey plan detailed how the taller scheme was never approved and the safety-coordinator rules were never triggered. The Department of Buildings first blamed unsafe construction next door, then retracted that finding as premature and inaccurate.
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez has opened a criminal investigation into whether criminal conduct contributed to the collapse, as covered in our report on the criminal inquiry. No charges have been filed.
Demolition is a last resort for a damaged building, and the city says every other option was ruled out. Shoring up a structure means sending crews inside to brace walls and floors, but the engineers found 1323 Flatbush too unstable for anyone to enter. With the adjoining wall gone, the building has weakened day by day rather than holding steady.
The controlled demolition will be carried out under the emergency declaration, which lets the city move faster than a standard permit. Fencing off the collapse zone keeps the public clear, and shoring 1325 Flatbush first is meant to protect the next building in the row. The asbestos adds another layer of care: the material must be handled safely so fibres do not spread to neighbouring homes and streets.
Buildings Commissioner Ahmed Tigani was blunt about why the city acted. "Ordering for the controlled safe demolition of the building is the only available option" given the danger, he said, adding the decision followed the engineers' finding.
The criminal investigation continues alongside the demolition. District Attorney Gonzalez has said his team is working with the Department of Buildings and police to "determine whether any criminal conduct contributed to this tragedy". Mayor Mamdani has promised accountability, saying "we will hold them fully accountable". For the displaced families, the order confirms that the homes they fled on November 11 are gone for good.
The demolition order shows how far the damage from one collapse can reach. The eight deaths at 1321 Flatbush were the immediate tragedy, but the building next door is now a second casualty, and two more remain under vacate orders. A single excavation, on a project approved for only three storeys, has displaced several households and fenced off a stretch of Flatbush Avenue.
It is also a test of how the city handles dangerous buildings after a fatal failure. The department is sweeping more than 160 work sites tied to the same project team, a scale that suggests officials are looking for a pattern rather than a single mistake. Whatever the investigation finds, the demolition will stand as the visible cost of the collapse, and the criminal inquiry will decide whether anyone bears legal responsibility.
Crews will first shore up 1325 Flatbush Avenue, then bring down 1323 Flatbush under the emergency declaration. The Department of Buildings will keep investigating the cause of the collapse, and the district attorney's criminal inquiry continues in parallel. The vacate orders at 1325 and 1327 Flatbush will stay until engineers judge those buildings safe.
The city has not said when demolition will begin or how long the collapse zone will stay fenced off.
Why is 1323 Flatbush Avenue being demolished?
Forensic engineers found it too unstable to enter and shore up after it lost its adjoining wall in the November 11 collapse next door.
How many people died in the Flatbush collapse?
Eight people were killed, including two children, and 18 injured when 1321 Flatbush Avenue collapsed into an excavation on November 11.
Can tenants go back to collect their belongings?
No. Tenants cannot re-enter because of the structural danger and heavy asbestos contamination.
What is happening to the neighbouring buildings?
The city will shore up 1325 Flatbush Avenue first, and vacate orders at 1325 and 1327 Flatbush remain in effect.
Is anyone being held responsible for the collapse?
Brooklyn District Attorney Eric Gonzalez has opened a criminal inquiry, and the Department of Buildings is investigating the cause and sweeping more than 160 work sites. No charges have been filed.