
New Jersey has sued the Department of Homeland Security in federal court, accusing the agency of stonewalling a civil rights investigation into Delaney Hall, the Newark immigration detention centre where at least three people have died in custody. The lawsuit, filed on Tuesday, asks a judge to force Homeland Security to decide within seven days whether the facility's private operator may hand over records on medical care and the use of force.
Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and the state Division on Civil Rights filed the case, Davenport v. DHS, in federal court in Washington.
The lawsuit was filed on Tuesday, November 17, in the US District Court for the District of Columbia, alleging that Homeland Security violated the Administrative Procedure Act by failing to respond to the state's requests.
The dispute began on August 7, when the Division on Civil Rights opened its investigation into possible civil rights violations at Delaney Hall and issued a subpoena to The GEO Group the same day. The subpoena sought records on medical screenings, staff qualifications, infectious-disease controls and the use of force at the 1,196-bed facility, which GEO owns and runs under a contract with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
GEO declined to produce the records, saying it needed permission from Homeland Security first. New Jersey argues that GEO, as a private company operating in New Jersey, does not need the department's permission to hand the material over.
Delaney Hall has been at the centre of the national immigration debate for more than a year. In May 2025, a confrontation outside the facility led to the arrest of Newark Mayor Ras Baraka and criminal charges against Representative LaMonica McIver, who was accused of interfering with federal officers.
The facility is run by The GEO Group, one of the largest private prison operators in the United States. GEO completed the sale of its 1,635-bed Northwest ICE Processing Center in Tacoma, Washington, to the federal government for 453 million dollars earlier this month.
New Jersey's investigation is not the state's only legal dispute over Delaney Hall. The state separately sued GEO in June after health inspectors were turned away from the facility's medical unit.
The investigation was opened after at least three people died while in GEO's custody at Delaney Hall, amid reports of inadequate medical care, violence and other concerns. Investigators have received reports of detainees not getting medication for chronic illnesses, poor responses to medical emergencies, physical and sexual harm, and a lack of disability accommodations and language interpretation services.
One of the deaths is documented in an internal ICE review cited in the complaint. Jean Wilson Brutus died on December 12, 2025, less than a day after arriving at the facility. The review found that medical staff failed to recognise that he was in cardiac arrest.
Attorney General Davenport did not hide her frustration in the announcement of the lawsuit. "There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall. But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling," she said in the release from her office.
Homeland Security, for its part, did not address the subpoena in its response. The department said ICE facilities are regularly audited and that detainees receive proper meals, water, blankets and medical treatment. The GEO Group has not publicly explained why it believes it needs federal permission before it can release records to a state civil rights investigation.
The case tests how far a state can go in investigating a privately run federal detention facility inside its borders. New Jersey's argument is straightforward: GEO is a private company operating in New Jersey, and the state's civil rights laws apply to it regardless of who its client is. If the court agrees, the state could finally see the medical and use-of-force records it has sought since August.
It also matters because the deaths at the centre of the investigation are not abstract. Three people have died in custody at Delaney Hall, and an internal federal review has already found that medical staff missed a cardiac arrest in one of those cases.
The court will now decide whether to order Homeland Security to rule within seven days on whether GEO may release the records.
Related coverage: Appeals court rejects McIver immunity rehearing 10-3, trial to proceed, GEO Group sells Tacoma ICE detention center to US for 453 million dollars and Pregnant US citizen pepper-sprayed by ICE agents outside Modesto jail in California.
Why is New Jersey suing the Department of Homeland Security?
The state says Homeland Security has stonewalled its civil rights investigation into Delaney Hall by refusing for more than three months to decide whether GEO may release subpoenaed records on medical care and the use of force.
What is Delaney Hall?
A 1,196-bed immigration detention centre in Newark, New Jersey, owned and operated by The GEO Group under a contract with Immigration and Customs Enforcement.
How many people have died at Delaney Hall?
At least three, according to the state. Jean Wilson Brutus died on December 12, 2025, less than a day after arriving, and an internal ICE review found medical staff failed to recognise his cardiac arrest.
What does the lawsuit ask the court to do?
To order Homeland Security, under the Administrative Procedure Act, to decide within seven days whether GEO may release the records the state subpoenaed in August.
Has New Jersey sued over Delaney Hall before?
Yes. The state sued GEO in June after health inspectors were turned away from the medical unit, and the facility was the scene of the May 2025 confrontation that led to charges against Representative LaMonica McIver.