Judge Refuses to Pause Ruling That LA Prosecutor Bill Essayli Serves Unlawfully
A federal judge in California has refused to freeze his ruling that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as the top federal prosecutor in Los Angeles, rejecting the Justice Department's request to pause the order while it appeals and setting a November 23 deadline that could force a leadership change in the largest federal prosecutorial district in the United States.
Senior U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright, ruling on Monday, November 16, 2026, said the government had failed to identify any specific harm it would suffer if the ruling took effect, and found that its appeal to the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals had "a low likelihood of success." The decision keeps his October 27 order in place. The disqualification takes effect next Monday, November 23, unless a higher court intervenes.
Key Points
- Judge J. Michael Seabright refused on November 16 to stay his October 27 ruling that Bill Essayli is unlawfully serving as U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California.
- Seabright said the Justice Department failed to show any specific harm from letting the ruling take effect and found its appeal had "a low likelihood of success."
- The disqualification takes effect on Monday, November 23, unless a higher court intervenes, barring Essayli from the Ramirez and Tran prosecutions.
- The Justice Department warned the issue "potentially affects 5,000 cases in the largest district in the country," a claim the judge called unsupported.
- Essayli was sworn in as interim U.S. attorney in April 2025, resigned after the 120-day limit, and was reinstalled as first assistant, a move the judge ruled cannot keep him in charge without Senate confirmation.
What Happened
The Justice Department asked Judge Seabright to freeze his October 27 ruling while it appeals to the 9th Circuit, arguing it should not take effect before a higher court could review it. Seabright refused, concluding the government had shown no concrete injury and the appeal's prospects were weak.
Seabright did not dismiss the two prosecutions at the heart of the case: the Ramirez felon-in-possession firearms case and the Tran case, involving property stolen from interstate shipment. The indictments stand. What changes on November 23 is who may run them. Essayli would be barred from participating in or supervising either prosecution unless a higher court steps in first. The department warned the dispute reaches beyond two cases, saying the issue "potentially affects 5,000 cases in the largest district in the country," a figure Seabright called unsupported.
Background: How Essayli Came to Lead the Office
Bill Essayli was sworn in as interim U.S. attorney for the Central District of California in April 2025. Federal law allows an interim U.S. attorney to serve for 120 days. When that period expired without a Senate-confirmed appointment, Essayli resigned from the interim post. Then-Attorney General Pam Bondi then reinstalled him as first assistant U.S. attorney, and he continued to run the office from that position.
That sequence is what Judge Seabright struck down on October 27. The judge found that the title switch could not lawfully keep Essayli in charge without Senate confirmation, and that he was serving as a "de facto" U.S. attorney. The ruling followed a 9th Circuit decision rejecting the same tactic for another interim prosecutor, Sigal Chattah in Nevada. The case reached Seabright through the two prosecutions, whose defence lawyers argued Essayli had no lawful authority to supervise them. The judge agreed. Monday's decision closes the window for a stay.
Bill Essayli and the Unlawful Prosecutor Ruling
At the centre of the dispute is a basic constitutional rule. The U.S. attorney for a federal district must be nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. Congress created a narrow exception letting an interim appointee serve for 120 days, and letting a court appoint an interim after that, but it is not meant to become a permanent route around confirmation.
Seabright's ruling found that the administration had done exactly that: used the first assistant title to keep Essayli running the office indefinitely after his interim term expired, without putting his name to the Senate. His refusal to stay the ruling signals he sees little chance the 9th Circuit will disagree. The broader question is already before the Supreme Court in United States v. Jackson, No. 26-304, which examines the interim-appointment tactic. Essayli has said the matter "will be decided by the Supreme Court."
Reactions and Quotes
Judge Seabright's order was blunt about the government's case. He found that the Justice Department had failed to identify any specific harm it would suffer if the ruling took effect, and he concluded that its appeal to the 9th Circuit had "a low likelihood of success."
Why It Matters
The Central District of California is the largest federal prosecutorial district in the country by population, covering Los Angeles, Orange County, Riverside, San Bernardino, Ventura, Santa Barbara and San Luis Obispo counties. Its U.S. attorney supervises hundreds of prosecutors and thousands of cases, from drug trafficking and fraud to national security and public corruption. A ruling that its leader serves unlawfully therefore carries weight well beyond one office.
What Happens Next
Three dates now matter. The first is Monday, November 23, when the disqualification takes effect unless a higher court intervenes. The second is the 9th Circuit's ruling on the Justice Department's appeal. The third is the Supreme Court's ruling in United States v. Jackson, which could settle the question for the whole country.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who is Bill Essayli?
Bill Essayli is the interim U.S. attorney turned first assistant U.S. attorney who has led the Central District of California, covering Los Angeles, since April 2025. He served as interim U.S. attorney, resigned after the 120-day limit, and was reinstalled as first assistant, a move a federal judge has ruled unlawful.
What did Judge Seabright rule on October 27?
Judge J. Michael Seabright ruled that Essayli is unlawfully serving as a "de facto" U.S. attorney, because the first assistant title cannot keep him in charge without Senate confirmation. He barred Essayli from the Ramirez and Tran prosecutions.
What happens on November 23?
The disqualification takes effect on Monday, November 23, unless a higher court intervenes. Essayli would then be barred from the two prosecutions, and the office would need a lawful leader.
Does the ruling dismiss the Ramirez and Tran cases?
No. The indictments stand. The judge found no substantial prejudice, so both cases continue without Essayli's participation or supervision.
Read our earlier report on the October ruling that Bill Essayli serves unlawfully, and the Tampa case in which Essayli vowed to prosecute "to the fullest extent of federal law". For wider Justice Department context, see our report on the California voter-list dispute.
Leave a Comment