Prosecutors Sue to Block Newsom's Death Row Commutation of 548 Inmates in California
SACRAMENTO — Prosecutors and the families of murder victims have asked the California Supreme Court to block Governor Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute all 548 death sentences in the state, arguing the governor broke the law by moving to erase the sentences without giving victims and district attorneys the hearing the law requires. The petition, filed on Monday, asks the state’s highest court to stop Newsom from granting any commutations while the case is considered. The case, Friend v. Newsom, was brought by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation on behalf of 30 county district attorneys and 31 family members of murder victims.
Key Points
- The petition, filed Monday, November 16, asks the California Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute all 548 death sentences to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
- The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed the case for 30 county district attorneys and 31 relatives of murder victims.
- The petition says Newsom failed to notify victims and prosecutors, denying grieving families the chance to be heard, as state law requires.
- Newsom announced the commutations on November 5, calling it one of the hardest decisions of his time in office. The plan covers 529 men and 19 women.
- The constitution requires the court’s approval for clemency for anyone convicted of more than one felony, so judges must approve 382 of the 548 commutations.
What Happened
On Monday, November 16, the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed a petition with the California Supreme Court asking the justices to block the governor’s commutation plan and to stay any grants while the case is considered, before any of the 548 sentences can be changed.
The petitioners are 30 county district attorneys and more than two dozen relatives of murder victims, 31 family members in total, according to the Horvitz & Levy law firm. Their argument is procedural: the law requires victims and district attorneys to be notified and given an opportunity to be heard before a commutation decision, and, they say, Newsom did neither. The filing came less than two weeks after Newsom announced on November 5 that he would commute every death sentence in California to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
Background and Context
California has not carried out an execution since 2006, when Clarence Ray Allen was put to death, and it has carried out only 13 executions since voters restored capital punishment in 1978, even as its death row grew into the largest in the nation. Within weeks of taking office in 2019, Newsom imposed a moratorium on executions and closed the state’s execution chamber.
The moratorium stopped executions but left the sentences in place. The November 5 commutations are different: they change the sentences themselves, permanently removing the prospect of execution, though the order is not a repeal and frees no one. The plan drew an immediate backlash, and President Donald Trump attacked the commutations on November 15, calling the plan a disaster for justice.
The Newsom Death Row Commutation Lawsuit
The heart of the lawsuit is the notice requirement. The petition argues Newsom exceeded his authority by failing to notify victims and district attorneys, denying grieving relatives an “opportunity to be heard before a commutation decision” as state law requires. In its starkest line, the petition says: “Only this court can stop the governor’s disregard of the law — his abuse of power.”
The case also turns on a constitutional rule requiring the Supreme Court’s approval for clemency for anyone convicted of more than one felony, so the court must approve 382 of the proposed commutations individually. Newsom’s office says the penal code notice provision “does not apply when the governor acts on his own initiative to grant clemency absent a request.” Whether a governor acting on his own initiative owes victims and prosecutors notice and a hearing is now the central question before the court.
Reactions and Quotes
For the prosecutors and families behind the petition, the case is about the process owed to victims, not only about the sentences themselves. They say relatives who waited years, in some cases decades, for a final reckoning in a murder case learned of the commutations from the governor’s announcement, with no chance to speak before the decision was made.
The governor’s office has defended the plan as a lawful exercise of the clemency power, and Newsom has called the commutations a moral decision about a punishment he believes the state should no longer carry out. The clash tests two competing principles: a governor’s broad clemency power, and a victims’ rights framework California voters have strengthened over the years.
Why It Matters
The case matters because of its scale and its precedent. No governor has attempted to commute an entire death row of this size in a single act, and no court has ruled on whether a governor may do so without first notifying victims and prosecutors. The court’s answer will define the limits of executive clemency in California for years to come.
It also matters for the families, for whom a death sentence is often the final word a court has given them; the petition argues the law guarantees them a voice before that word is erased. Beyond California, other governors are watching, because a ruling here could be cited in clemency fights in other states.
What Happens Next
The first question before the California Supreme Court is whether to grant the stay the petitioners requested, freezing any commutation grants while the case is considered. If the court grants it, the 548 sentences stay in place until the justices rule. If it declines, the governor could begin granting the commutations while the legal challenge continues.
After that, the court will decide whether to take up the case in full and set a briefing schedule. The 382 cases requiring the court’s approval will also need the justices’ attention, one by one, even if the broader challenge fails. Until the court acts, the commutations remain announced but not granted.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the lawsuit asking for?
Prosecutors and victims’ families ask the California Supreme Court to block Gov. Gavin Newsom’s plan to commute all 548 death sentences, and to stay any grants while the case is considered.
Who filed the case?
The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation filed the petition, Friend v. Newsom, for 30 county district attorneys and 31 family members of murder victims.
Why do they say the commutations are unlawful?
They argue Newsom failed to notify victims and district attorneys, denying grieving relatives an opportunity to be heard, as state law requires.
How many people are on California’s death row?
There are 548 people on death row in California, 529 men and 19 women, the largest death row in the United States.
What happens next?
The court will first decide whether to stay the commutations, and must approve 382 of them individually under the constitution.
Leave a Comment