US News Pulse Newsroom
Editorial Team
Published : Nov 21, 2026
Online Edition

Fifth Circuit Proxy Vote Ruling: House Passed $1.7 Trillion Bill Unconstitutionally

Fifth Circuit Proxy Vote Ruling: House Passed $1.7 Trillion Bill Unconstitutionally

The Fifth Circuit proxy vote ruling landed on Friday, November 20, 2026, when the New Orleans-based 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals voted 9-8 to uphold an injunction blocking enforcement of a pregnant-workers protection in the $1.7 trillion 2022 funding bill. The court held that the House of Representatives unconstitutionally passed the bill through a pandemic-era proxy voting rule, because the Constitution's quorum clause requires a majority of House members to be physically present to pass legislation.

Key Points

  • The 5th US Circuit Court of Appeals voted 9-8 on Friday, November 20, 2026, to uphold an injunction against a pregnant-workers provision in the $1.7 trillion 2022 bill.
  • The court held the House unconstitutionally passed the bill by pandemic-era proxy vote, saying the quorum clause requires a majority of members to be physically present.
  • The bill passed the House 225-201, with 226 members voting by proxy, a number larger than the 24-vote margin of passage.
  • The relief is narrow: it bars the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the provision against Texas only.
  • Judge Cory Wilson, a Trump appointee, wrote the majority; Judge James Graves, an Obama appointee, dissented, calling it "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid".

What Happened

The full 5th Circuit, sitting en banc, upheld an injunction that outgoing Republican Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton secured, blocking enforcement of a provision of the $1.7 trillion 2022 government funding bill that gave pregnant workers stronger legal protections. The provision is part of the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, which was included in the sprawling omnibus spending package Congress passed in December 2022.

The case turned on how the bill was passed, not the protection itself. The House approved the $1.7 trillion package 225-201, but 226 members voted by proxy under a pandemic-era rule letting a colleague on the floor vote for them. The court said that violated the Constitution, because the quorum clause requires a majority of members to be physically present. The 9-8 vote shows how divided the court was.

Background and Context

The proxy voting rule at the heart of the case was born in the first months of COVID-19. Then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi implemented it in May 2020 as an emergency measure, letting members who could not travel to Washington have another member vote by proxy. It stayed in place for more than two years and was used to pass major legislation during the pandemic.

Republicans dropped the proxy rule when they took control of the House after the November 2022 elections. But the $1.7 trillion bill passed in December 2022, in the final weeks of Democratic control, while the rule was still in force, and President Joe Biden signed it into law. Texas challenged the law, and Paxton won an injunction in the lower court. The Pregnant Workers Fairness Act requires employers to give pregnant workers reasonable accommodations, and the ruling does not strike it down nationwide.

The Proxy Vote Ruling and the Quorum Clause

The majority's reasoning rests on the quorum clause, which says a majority of each House shall constitute a quorum to do business. The court read that to mean a majority of members must actually be present, in person, when the House passes a bill. A proxy vote, in the majority's view, does not count toward physical presence.

The numbers make the point concrete: the bill passed 225-201, a margin of just 24 votes, while 226 members voted by proxy, more than the margin itself. The dissent, led by Judge Graves, took the opposite view: the Constitution leaves each chamber to set its own rules, and allowing proxy voting during a pandemic fell within that power. The 9-8 split means the court itself was nearly evenly divided on a question at the heart of how Congress functions.

Reactions and Statements

Judge Graves's dissent is the sharpest reaction on the record so far, calling the majority's ruling "illogical, inexplicable, and invalid". The phrase captures the view of the eight judges in dissent: that the court has second-guessed a procedural choice the Constitution leaves to the House itself.

Paxton secured the injunction the court has now upheld, a significant win for his office in its final weeks. The Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, the agencies now barred from enforcing the provision against Texas, have not yet said whether they will seek further review.

Why It Matters

The ruling puts a constitutional cloud over one of the largest spending bills in American history. The $1.7 trillion package funded the federal government and carried major policy measures, including the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act. The bill itself is not voided, but the reasoning could be used to challenge other measures passed under the proxy rule.

It also speaks to remote work in Congress: the House's proxy rule was America's version of the pandemic experiment with remote voting, and the 5th Circuit has now said that experiment crossed a constitutional line. And it matters for pregnant workers in Texas, where federal agencies can no longer enforce that protection, while workers elsewhere are unaffected. The timing adds weight, with Democrats taking control of both chambers in January.

What Happens Next

The most likely next step is a request for Supreme Court review. The 9-8 split, the constitutional question and the stakes for pandemic-era legislation make the case a strong candidate. The Justice Department could ask the justices to reverse the 5th Circuit, and Texas could defend the ruling. Until the court decides whether to take the case, the injunction stands.

Congress may also respond. The new Congress taking office in January could reaffirm the 2022 bill, pass a fresh version of the pregnant-workers provision, or change House rules for emergencies. Other states are watching too: if Texas can block a federal workplace protection on quorum grounds, others could try the same argument.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did the 5th Circuit rule?
By 9-8, the court upheld an injunction blocking the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act provision of the $1.7 trillion 2022 bill against Texas, holding the House passed it unconstitutionally by proxy vote.

What is proxy voting?
A pandemic-era House rule, introduced by then-Speaker Nancy Pelosi in May 2020, letting a member on the floor vote for an absent colleague. Republicans dropped it after the November 2022 elections.

Does the ruling void the whole $1.7 trillion bill?
No. It bars the Justice Department and the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission from enforcing the pregnant-workers provision against Texas. The rest of the bill is unaffected.

What is the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act?
A federal law in the 2022 funding bill requiring employers to give pregnant workers reasonable accommodations, such as extra breaks or limits on heavy lifting.

What happens next?
The Justice Department could ask the Supreme Court to review the 9-8 decision, and Congress could act in January. Until then, the injunction in Texas stands.

Read more: Trump Administration Plans to Narrow Pregnant Workers Protections Under PWFA Rule | Senate Confirms Daniel Domenico to Tenth Circuit 51-46 in Lame-Duck Push | Judge Rejects Trump's $4 Billion Homelessness Revamp, Blocks $1.3 Billion Shift

US News Pulse
Written by
US News Pulse Newsroom
Editorial Team

The US News Pulse newsroom covers breaking news across the United States and the world, working from wire services, official statements and on-the-record sources. Every story is reviewed against our editorial standards before publication. Corrections and tips: info@usnewspulse.com

About our newsroom

Leave a Comment

  • Latest
  • Popular

Senate Confirms Anna St. John to Fifth Circuit 52-46 in Lame

1

Estonia to Close All Russia Border Crossings From December 1

2

Restauración de Derechos de Armas Reabre Tras 30 Años: el DO

3

Kushner Pushes Direct Europe-Russia Talks as Five Nations Se

4

Irán afirma que derribó un dron MQ-9 Reaper de EE. UU. al es

5

Lake Tahoe Winter Storm Watch: Up to 3 Feet of Snow and 80 M

6

Comer lanza su candidatura a gobernador de Kentucky con impu

7

Crimea Bridge Hit a Third Time in a Week as Traffic Halts Be

8

Virginia Senate Leader Louise Lucas Pleads Not Guilty in Fed

9

NTSB Says Steering Failure Sent New Orleans Tanker Into Dock

10

Baréin da por terminada la alerta mientras Kuwait repele ata

11

Louisville Edges North Carolina 16-14 as Mack's Late Pick Se

12

Departamento de Energía ordena que la planta de carbón Campb

13

Trump's RNC Chair Joe Gruters Faces Rebellion as Crosbie Cha

14

Union Pacific CEO's Rate Threat Puts $71.5 Billion Norfolk S

15

Forensic Expert Tells BBC Epstein Was Strangled, Not Suicide

16

Jeffrey Epstein Courted Russian Oligarchs in Bid to Meet Put

17

Sharks Beat Predators 4-2 to Snap Nashville's Seven-Game Win

18

Texas Tech, número 12, aplasta 52-27 a Oklahoma State y sigu

19

Florida sorprende 21-14 a Kentucky, número 13, con un gol ta

20