Medicare Advantage Star Ratings: UnitedHealth Sues US Government for 2027
UnitedHealth Group, the largest Medicare Advantage insurer in the United States, has sued the federal government over its 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings, arguing that flawed calculations by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) are costing it bonus payments worth potentially billions of dollars — and threatening benefits for the 7.61 million older and disabled Americans enrolled in its plans.
The complaint, filed late on Thursday, November 19, 2026, in federal court in Brunswick, Georgia, says CMS improperly used 26 measures to calculate ratings for 45 UnitedHealth contracts. The insurer argues the agency lacked the statutory authority to use those measures, failed to give the company a chance to object, or both. UnitedHealth called the ratings the government’s “principal signal” to patients about plan quality, and warned low scores could cut preventive care and push premiums higher. CMS declined to comment.
Key Points
- UnitedHealth filed the complaint late on Thursday, November 19, 2026, in federal court in Brunswick, Georgia, over the 2027 star ratings for 45 of its contracts.
- The insurer says CMS improperly used 26 measures to calculate the ratings, arguing the agency lacked statutory authority, failed to give it a chance to object, or both.
- UnitedHealth says the ratings for those 45 contracts would rise by at least 0.5 stars — and by as much as 1.5 stars — if CMS calculated them properly.
- CVS Health sued CMS over the same ratings last month, saying it could lose more than $2 billion in bonus payments and rebate retention; Humana filed a similar lawsuit in 2024.
- The case was assigned to US District Judge Lisa Godbey Wood, who in May 2026 ruled that CMS had calculated an incorrect star rating for Clover Health and ordered a recalculation.
What Happened
UnitedHealth asked the federal court in Brunswick, Georgia, to throw out the 2027 Medicare Advantage star ratings for 45 of its contracts. In the complaint, the company says CMS built those ratings using 26 measures it should never have used — measures the agency had no statutory authority to apply, or applied without giving UnitedHealth a chance to object.
The insurer says the ratings threaten “imminent harm” by depriving it of bonus payments and lowering benefits for patients. It argues that if CMS calculated the ratings properly, the scores would rise by at least half a star, and by as much as a star and a half in some cases.
Background and Context
CMS released its 2027 star ratings last month, and the results have already drawn more than one lawsuit. CVS Health, the parent of Aetna, sued last month, saying it could lose more than $2 billion in bonus payments and rebate retention. Humana filed a similar lawsuit in 2024,
UnitedHealth served about 7.61 million patients under Medicare Advantage as of September 30, 2026, and holds a 30 percent share of the market, followed by Humana and CVS, according to the American Medical Association. Medicare Advantage, also known as Part C, lets people who opt out of traditional Medicare enrol in private health plans instead. People aged 65 and older, or with disabilities, are eligible for Medicare. For insurers, the ratings are a financial lifeline: higher-rated plans receive bonus payments that can reach hundreds of millions or billions of dollars if costs stay low.
Medicare Advantage Star Ratings: How the System Works
Medicare Advantage star ratings run from one star for poor performance to five stars for excellent, and they are meant to tell patients how well a plan delivers care. CMS builds each rating from dozens of quality measures, covering how plans handle preventive screening, chronic conditions, customer service, complaints and how quickly members can get the care they need.
The ratings are published each autumn for the following plan year, and they carry real money. Plans rated four stars or higher earn bonus payments from the government, which can reach hundreds of millions or billions of dollars if costs stay low. Insurers advertise their star ratings, brokers highlight them, and patients use them to choose between plans during open enrolment. That is the heart of UnitedHealth’s complaint: not that the star system is wrong in principle, but that CMS fed it the wrong inputs for 45 contracts.
Reactions and Quotes
UnitedHealth said it had not taken the decision to sue lightly. “We did not take this step lightly,” the Eden Prairie, Minnesota-based company said in a statement about the lawsuit. “We remain committed to working with CMS to modernize the Stars program and create a more durable approach to measuring quality.”
CMS, part of the Department of Health and Human Services, declined to comment. The agency has not publicly responded to the claim that it lacked authority for the 26 measures, or that it denied UnitedHealth a chance to object.
Why It Matters
For the 7.61 million people enrolled in UnitedHealth’s Medicare Advantage plans, the case is about more than a corporate dispute over bonus payments. The company says improperly low ratings could reduce its ability to offer preventive care and raise premiums
For taxpayers, the stakes are just as large. The bonus payments at issue are public money, paid to reward plans that deliver better care at lower cost. If ratings are calculated wrongly, the government may be paying bonuses to the wrong plans — or withholding them from plans that earned them. UnitedHealth calls the ratings the government’s “principal signal” to patients about plan quality, and a court finding that CMS used measures it had no authority to use would raise questions about how much confidence patients should place in the scores,
What Happens Next
CMS is expected to respond to the complaint in the coming weeks, and the early schedule in Judge Wood’s courtroom will show how quickly the case moves. UnitedHealth has framed the harm as imminent, which suggests it may seek relief before the 2027 ratings take full effect, though no hearing date has been announced.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are Medicare Advantage star ratings?
One-to-five-star scores CMS gives private Medicare Advantage plans each year. Higher-rated plans earn government bonus payments.
Why is UnitedHealth suing CMS?
UnitedHealth says CMS improperly used 26 measures to calculate the 2027 ratings for 45 of its contracts, without statutory authority or a chance to object, and that the ratings would rise by 0.5 to 1.5 stars if calculated properly.
How many patients does UnitedHealth cover under Medicare Advantage?
About 7.61 million patients as of September 30, 2026, giving it a 30 percent share of the market, the largest of any insurer.
Have other insurers sued over star ratings?
Yes. CVS sued last month over the same ratings, saying it could lose more than $2 billion, and Humana sued in 2024.
What happens if UnitedHealth wins?
CMS could be ordered to recalculate the ratings for the 45 contracts, restoring bonus payments and forcing a wider rethink of how the Stars program is built for future years.
Read more on US News Pulse: Medicare AI prior authorization cut care by 15 to 20 percent in six states, study finds and Medicare ousts two surprise billing arbitrators as doctor payouts hit $15 billion.
Leave a Comment