Trump's Board of Peace Faults Israel and Hamas Over Gaza War - US News Pulse
The Board of Peace Gaza report delivers a blunt verdict on the fragile truce: more than a year after the United States brokered a ceasefire, neither Israel nor Hamas has kept its promises. The 12-page assessment, seen by Reuters on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, is the board's second report to the UN Security Council, and it warns a ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot survive.
Key Points
- The Board of Peace, headed by President Donald Trump, says both Israel and Hamas have failed to meet their commitments to end hostilities in Gaza.
- The 12-page report, seen by Reuters on November 18, 2026, is the board's second to the UN Security Council since the ceasefire took effect 13 months ago.
- More than 1,600 Palestinians and five Israeli soldiers have died in Gaza since the October 2025 ceasefire.
- Hamas agreed in July to a roadmap to surrender its weapons, but Israel rejected it and will not withdraw until Hamas is dismantled.
- The board will present its findings to the Security Council in New York at the end of November.
What Happened
The Board of Peace was established and is headed by President Trump to oversee his Gaza plan. Its new report is its second formal assessment for the UN Security Council since the ceasefire took effect 13 months ago, and the board will present the findings in New York at the end of November.
At the heart of the report is a warning that the gap between what was promised and what is happening on the ground is now the greatest danger to the process. "The distance between what has been agreed and what is happening on the ground nonetheless remains the principal risk to the process," the report says, adding that "a ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely."
The report says the commitment to cease all military activities "has not been met in full by the parties": Israel has carried out near-daily strikes on Gaza, while Hamas fighters have continued attacks on Israeli troops.
Read our report on President Trump pressing Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to advance the Gaza peace plan.
Background and Context
The ceasefire was struck in October 2025 under an American-mediated deal, and the Board of Peace was created to shepherd it through disarmament, the transfer of power to a civilian transitional authority, reconstruction and the phased withdrawal of Israeli forces. Thirteen months on, almost none of that has been completed.
Hamas agreed in July to a Board of Peace roadmap to surrender its weapons and transfer governance to a civilian transitional authority. Israel rejected it, saying it will not withdraw until Hamas is dismantled, and Defence Minister Israel Katz said on Wednesday, November 18, that Israel would not withdraw until Hamas was dismantled and Gaza demilitarised.
More than 1,600 Palestinians, including many civilians, and five Israeli soldiers have been killed in Gaza since the deal was struck. The wider war has killed 74,000 Palestinians since the October 2023 Hamas attacks that killed around 1,200 people in Israel.
More than two million Palestinians now live confined to around a third of Gaza, mostly in makeshift tents and damaged buildings, while Israel occupies the other two-thirds, largely razed and depopulated.
Board of Peace Gaza Report: What the Findings Mean
The report spreads its criticism across both sides. It criticised Israel's government for an "absence of decisions" on training and deploying a civilian Palestinian police force, a step essential to restoring order, and said Israeli restrictions on supplies and equipment, plus funding shortfalls, hindered preparations for flooding as winter approaches.
On the Hamas side, the report said the group was collecting taxes on goods entering Gaza, hitting the availability of basic commodities for ordinary Palestinians. The finding underlines the board's central complaint: both parties are still defending their own leverage rather than the agreement they signed.
Read our report on Hamas disarmament stalling as Netanyahu says no weapons have been surrendered in Gaza.
The deadlock over disarmament remains the core obstacle: Hamas agreed to the July roadmap, but Israel's refusal has left the plan without a path forward, and the board makes clear that international patience is wearing thin.
Reactions and Quotes
Defence Minister Israel Katz restated Israel's position on Wednesday, November 18: Israel would not withdraw from Gaza until Hamas was dismantled and Gaza demilitarised. The statement leaves no room for the phased withdrawal the plan envisages.
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office and a spokesperson for Hamas's political office did not immediately respond to requests for comment, and neither party has publicly accepted any share of the blame.
The report's own words carry the sharpest message. "The distance between what has been agreed and what is happening on the ground nonetheless remains the principal risk to the process," it warns, and its conclusion that "a ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely" is a direct challenge to both governments to show results before the end of the month.
Why It Matters
The Board of Peace is not an outside critic: it is the body President Trump created to run his Gaza plan, and its second report amounts to an admission from inside the process that the deal is failing. The ceasefire was the centrepiece of the administration's Middle East policy, and its collapse would leave Gaza with no agreed framework at all.
It also matters for the more than two million Palestinians living in tents and damaged buildings, with winter approaching and flood preparations already hindered, and for the region, because a ceasefire without visible progress risks a return to full-scale fighting.
What Happens Next
The board is expected to present its findings to the UN Security Council in New York at the end of November, putting the report before the world's governments and forcing a public debate on the ceasefire.
Before then, attention will fall on whether Israel softens its refusal of the July roadmap, whether Hamas takes any concrete step toward disarmament, and whether the promised civilian police force and flood preparations move forward. Without movement on at least one front, the board's warning may prove a prediction rather than a warning.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Board of Peace? It is the body established and headed by President Donald Trump to oversee his Gaza plan: disarmament, civilian governance, reconstruction and the phased withdrawal of Israeli forces.
What does the new report say? In its second report to the UN Security Council, the board says both sides failed to meet their commitments to end hostilities, and warns the ceasefire cannot be sustained without visible progress.
How many people have been killed since the ceasefire? More than 1,600 Palestinians, including many civilians, and five Israeli soldiers have died in Gaza since the October 2025 ceasefire.
Why has the Gaza plan stalled? Hamas agreed in July to a roadmap to surrender its weapons, but Israel rejected it and will not withdraw until Hamas is dismantled and Gaza demilitarised.
When will the board present its findings? The board will present the report to the UN Security Council in New York at the end of November.
Leave a Comment