US News Pulse Newsroom
Editorial Team
Published : Nov 19, 2026
Online Edition

Senate Committee Refuses to Vote on Trump's NSF Nominee O'Neill in Kennedy Rebuke

Senate Committee Refuses to Vote on Trump's NSF Nominee O'Neill in Kennedy Rebuke

The Senate committee that oversees science policy refused on Wednesday to advance Jim O'Neill, President Donald Trump's nominee to lead the National Science Foundation, a rare public rebuke from a chairman of the president's own party.

Senator Bill Cassidy, the Louisiana Republican who chairs the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, said during opening remarks at a hearing that O'Neill would not be considered to lead the NSF. The decision came hours after the White House pulled its FDA nominee, Heidi Overton, in a second setback for the administration's health and science appointments that day.

Key Points

  • Senate HELP Committee chair Bill Cassidy said on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, that Jim O'Neill would not be considered to lead the National Science Foundation.
  • Cassidy said O'Neill "did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements" from Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
  • Cassidy also cited O'Neill's role in the firing of CDC director Susan Monarez, saying it "raised further concerns about the independent judgment he would bring to NSF".
  • O'Neill previously served as acting CDC director and is widely seen as a key Kennedy ally and a proponent of the "Make America Healthy Again" movement.
  • The White House pulled its FDA nominee Heidi Overton hours earlier, and science groups had campaigned against O'Neill's nomination.

What Happened

Cassidy made the announcement at the start of a committee hearing on Wednesday, November 18, 2026. He did not put O'Neill's nomination to a vote and set no date for future consideration. A committee vote is the normal step before a nominee reaches the full Senate, so without it O'Neill's path to confirmation is effectively blocked unless the committee changes course.

The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment, and a spokesperson for the National Science Foundation declined to comment. O'Neill has not publicly responded to the committee's decision.

Background and Context

The National Science Foundation is the federal agency that funds much of the basic scientific research carried out at American universities, from physics and engineering to biology and computer science. Its director sets research priorities, oversees a budget of billions of dollars, and speaks for the agency in dealings with Congress and the White House. The job has often been filled by a prominent scientist with broad support across both parties.

O'Neill came to the nomination with a very different profile. He served as acting director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, where he worked closely with Kennedy. He is widely seen as a key Kennedy ally and a supporter of the "Make America Healthy Again" movement. Science groups, including the Union of Concerned Scientists, campaigned against the nomination, pointing to his time as acting CDC director and to his background in biotechnology investment rather than academic research. The Monarez firing sharpened those concerns: she was dismissed after a clash with Kennedy over vaccine policy, and Cassidy, a physician who has previously pressed Kennedy on vaccines, treated O'Neill's involvement as a warning sign.

Jim O'Neill NSF Nominee: Why the Senate Said No

The committee's refusal is striking because it came from a Republican chairman, not from the Democratic minority. Cassidy's framing put the issue squarely on scientific independence: a nominee to lead the NSF, he argued, must be willing to push back when political leaders make decisions or statements that contradict the evidence.

The decision also fits a wider pattern of tension between the Senate and the administration over science and health. The NSF has already been at the centre of legal fights this year, including a lawsuit by researchers seeking to stop the closure of its social sciences directorate. For the White House, the timing compounds the damage: hours before Cassidy spoke, the administration withdrew Heidi Overton, its nominee to lead the Food and Drug Administration, a day before her Senate vote. Two of the administration's most important science and health nominations stalled on the same day, both reflecting unease about the direction of Kennedy's health department.

Reactions and Quotes

"He did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements" from Kennedy, Cassidy said, according to Scientific American, which first reported the decision. On Monarez, he said O'Neill's role in her firing "raised further concerns about the independent judgment he would bring to NSF". Science advocacy groups welcomed the decision: the Union of Concerned Scientists had campaigned against the nomination, arguing that O'Neill's record as acting CDC director showed he would not protect the agency's independence. The White House offered no immediate defence of the nominee, and an NSF spokesperson declined to comment.

Why It Matters

The NSF funds the basic research that underpins American science, from university laboratories to the graduate students who staff them. Its director decides which fields get priority, how grant money is allocated, and how the agency responds when political pressure touches scientific questions. The episode also matters as a measure of the Senate's patience: Cassidy chairs the committee that handles the administration's nominations. His public refusal signals that concerns about Kennedy's management of the health agencies have reached Republican senators who control the confirmation process.

What Happens Next

O'Neill's nomination remains pending, but without a committee vote it cannot reach the Senate floor. The White House has three broad options: press Cassidy to schedule a vote, formally withdraw the nomination, or leave it untouched while the NSF continues under acting leadership. The committee could also revisit the nomination if O'Neill gives stronger assurances about the agency's independence. No such hearing has been announced. With the FDA nomination also withdrawn, the administration faces two vacancies at the top of its science and health agencies at once.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who is Jim O'Neill?

President Trump's nominee to lead the National Science Foundation. He previously served as acting director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and is widely seen as a close ally of Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.

Why did the Senate committee refuse to vote on his nomination?

Committee chair Bill Cassidy said O'Neill "did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements" from Kennedy, and cited his role in the firing of CDC director Susan Monarez.

What is the National Science Foundation?

The NSF is the federal agency that funds much of the basic scientific research at American universities, covering fields from physics and engineering to biology and computer science.

Does this mean O'Neill's nomination is dead?

Not formally, but without a committee vote a nomination cannot reach the full Senate. The White House would need the committee to change course, or it would have to withdraw the nomination or name someone else.

What happened to the FDA nominee on the same day?

The White House pulled its nominee to lead the Food and Drug Administration, Heidi Overton, hours before Cassidy's announcement, a day before her scheduled Senate vote.

Read more on US News Pulse: White House Withdraws FDA Nominee Heidi Overton a Day Before Senate Vote, National Science Foundation Sued Over Plan to Close Social Science Unit, and Supreme Court Rejects Trump Appeal Over $59 Million DEI Research Grant Cuts.

US News Pulse
Written by
US News Pulse Newsroom
Editorial Team

The US News Pulse newsroom covers breaking news across the United States and the world, working from wire services, official statements and on-the-record sources. Every story is reviewed against our editorial standards before publication. Corrections and tips: info@usnewspulse.com

About our newsroom

Leave a Comment

  • Latest
  • Popular

White House Weighs Pushing Out Commerce Secretary Lutnick Am

1

Iran Claims Drones Hit US Patriot Defences at Kuwait Air Bas

2

Piratas secuestran 4.837 cuentas de GitHub para propagar el

3

Gibran Rakabuming Raka Resigns as Indonesia Vice President A

4

La inteligencia de EE. UU. está dividida sobre si Alice Huan

5

Inundaciones en Florida: riesgo moderado poco común amenaza

6

Mossad Chief Gofman Lobbied US for Joint Strikes on Iran as

7

Kentucky escapa de Northern Arizona 78-77 con un triple de W

8

Kang Wei, Alice Huang's Husband, Introduced Her to Nvidia CE

9

Los Clippers remontan 113-112 ante los Thunder con la jugada

10

SpaceX Denies Starshield Speed Cap as Ukraine Says 100 mph L

11

Bank Outage Locks Out Chase, Bank of America and Wells Fargo

12

El uranio enriquecido de Irán no saldrá del país, jura Rezae

13

Mohamed Yusuf Attack: Uber Driver in Coma After Alleged Hate

14

Brote de E. coli en California: muere una niña y llega a un

15

Senador republicano de Oklahoma bloquea la nominación del ju

16

Hakeem Jeffries, nominado presidente de la Cámara en un hito

17

Padre acusado de intento de asesinato tras hallar vivo a su

18

Los Jets vencen 4-2 a los Devils con doblete de Mercer y abu

19

Ucrania Lanza su Mayor Ataque con Drones contra Rusia y Golp

20