Susan Smith Denied Parole a Second Time 32 Years After Drowning Her Sons
Susan Smith will stay in prison. South Carolina's Board of Paroles and Pardons unanimously denied her parole on Thursday, November 19, 2026, rejecting her second bid for freedom 32 years after she drowned her two young sons in a South Carolina lake.
The decision means Smith, 55, will remain at Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, where she has served 31 years of a life sentence for the 1994 murders of Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months. Under the board's two-year review cycle, she can ask for parole again in 2028.
Key Points
- South Carolina's parole board unanimously denied Susan Smith parole on Thursday, November 19, 2026, her second denial in two years.
- Smith, 55, has served 31 years of a life sentence for drowning her sons Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, in John D. Long Lake, Union, in October 1994.
- Appearing by video from Leath Correctional Institution, she told the board she was "not the same person" she was 32 years ago.
- Her ex-husband David Smith and the original prosecutors opposed her release in person, as in 2024.
- She needed five of seven votes; the board grants parole in only about 4 percent of cases.
What Happened
The seven-member Board of Paroles and Pardons heard Smith's case on Thursday, November 19, 2026, in Columbia. Smith appeared by video from Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, where she has spent more than three decades.
Smith testified on her own behalf, telling the board she was "not the same person" she was 32 years ago, when she let her car roll into John D. Long Lake with her two small sons strapped inside. Her ex-husband, David Smith, attended in person and spoke against her release, as he did at her first hearing in November 2024. The prosecutors who tried the case in 1995 also appeared in person to oppose parole.
Psychologist Jessie Hill testified that Smith's mental illness has been greatly subdued by medicine and the hormonal changes of menopause. To win parole, Smith needed the votes of at least five of the board's seven members. The board voted unanimously against her, the same result as her first hearing on November 20, 2024.
Background: The 1994 Case That Shocked America
In October 1994, Smith, then 23, told police a Black man had carjacked her burgundy Mazda in Union, South Carolina, and driven off with her two sons inside. For nine days the story gripped the nation as Smith pleaded on television for her children's return.
But the story was a lie. As details of Smith's account failed to add up, investigators grew suspicious, and on November 3, 1994, she confessed. She admitted there had been no carjacking: she had driven to John D. Long Lake herself, released the parking brake and let the car roll into the water with Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months, strapped in their seats. Divers later recovered the car and the boys' bodies from the lake.
Smith was tried in July 1995 in Union County. Prosecutors sought the death penalty, describing a mother who killed her children to clear the way for a relationship with a man who did not want children. The jury convicted her of two murders but chose life over death, with parole possible after 30 years. Strangers still leave toys and flowers at the lake.
Susan Smith Denied Parole: What the Board Decided
Thursday's decision was Smith's second parole denial. Her first hearing, on November 20, 2024, also ended in a unanimous vote against release. At that hearing, David Smith and 14 other witnesses gave emotional statements against her release.
The two hearings followed the same pattern. Smith, appearing by video, presented herself as a changed person, pointing to her mental health treatment and her behaviour in prison. Each time, her ex-husband and the prosecutors argued the opposite, and each time the board agreed. Five of seven votes would have freed her. Instead, not one member voted for release.
Reactions: A Father's Opposition and a Changed-Woman Plea
David Smith, the father of Michael and Alex, has opposed his ex-wife's release at every step. He attended Thursday's hearing in person, as he did in 2024 alongside 14 other witnesses. For David Smith, the case has never been about how much time has passed, but about what was done to his sons.
The prosecutors who secured Smith's conviction in 1995 also appeared in person to oppose parole. Their message was that the crime still outweighs the years Smith has served. On the other side, Smith's testimony and the evidence from psychologist Jessie Hill described a woman whose mental illness is now controlled by medicine and the hormonal changes of menopause. The board heard both sides and sided with the victims' family and the prosecutors.
Why It Matters
The Susan Smith case has never really left the American consciousness. It is taught in criminal justice courses and revisited in documentaries, and millions remember the nine-day search of 1994. Every hearing reopens the wound, and every denial reaffirms that some crimes carry a weight time alone cannot lift.
The decision also shows how South Carolina's parole system works in practice. The board grants parole in only about 4 percent of cases, mostly non-violent ones. For a prisoner convicted of murdering two children, the bar is far higher, and Thursday's vote shows good behaviour and treated illness are not enough on their own. Smith has spent 31 years in prison, more than half her life. The board's answer, twice now, is not yet.
What Happens Next
Smith will remain at Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood. Under the board's two-year review cycle, she can seek parole again in 2028, when she will be 57 and will have served 33 years. Her next hearing will likely follow the same pattern: Smith arguing she has changed, her ex-husband and the prosecutors opposing her release.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why was Susan Smith denied parole?
The board voted unanimously on November 19, 2026, to deny her second bid. Her ex-husband David Smith and the original prosecutors opposed her release in person.
What did Susan Smith do in 1994?
Smith falsely claimed a carjacker had taken her car with her sons inside, then confessed nine days later that she had let it roll into John D. Long Lake, drowning Michael, 3, and Alex, 14 months. She was convicted of murder in July 1995 and sentenced to life.
When was Susan Smith first denied parole?
Her first hearing was on November 20, 2024, also denied unanimously. David Smith and 14 other witnesses spoke against her release.
When can Susan Smith seek parole again?
She can next seek parole in 2028, under the two-year review cycle. She will be 57 and will have served 33 years.
Where is Susan Smith imprisoned?
She is held at Leath Correctional Institution in Greenwood, South Carolina, and appeared by video from the facility.
Read more on US News Pulse: Susan Smith Parole Hearing: Second Bid for Freedom Faces David Smith's Opposition and Baby Found Alive After Being Buried 24 Hours in Dog Crate in South Carolina Woods.
Leave a Comment