US News Pulse Newsroom
Editorial Team
Published : Nov 21, 2026
Online Edition

Judge Keeps Alex Murdaugh Murder Charges Alive for April 2027 Retrial in SC

Judge Keeps Alex Murdaugh Murder Charges Alive for April 2027 Retrial in SC

A South Carolina judge has refused to throw out the murder charges against Alex Murdaugh, ruling on Friday that the disgraced former lawyer will stand trial again in April 2027 for the killings of his wife and son.

Circuit Judge Debra McCaslin denied the motion to dismiss in an 11-page order in Lexington on Friday, November 20, 2026. No fresh indictments are needed, and the retrial begins the week of April 5, 2027, in Sumter County.

Key Points

  • Judge Debra McCaslin denied Alex Murdaugh's motion to dismiss his murder and weapons indictments on November 20, 2026, so all four July 2022 grand jury charges stand.
  • Even without the disputed testimony, the judge ruled, "the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause" for the indictments.
  • McCaslin found lead investigator David Owen failed to review a key lab report before testifying, a serious error, but not intentional bad faith.
  • The retrial begins the week of April 5, 2027, in Sumter County; the juror questionnaire is due January 20, 2027, and expert lists by March 1, 2027.
  • Murdaugh remains in prison on separate financial-crime sentences while he awaits retrial for the 2021 killings of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh.

What Happened

The ruling came a week after Murdaugh's lawyers argued at a hearing in Lexington on November 13 that the original indictments should be thrown out. The defence said SLED agent David Owen, the lead investigator, gave false or misleading testimony to the Colleton County grand jury in 2022 about blood spatter on a shirt Murdaugh wore that night and shotgun ammunition patterns matching a missing murder weapon.

McCaslin heard nearly two hours of arguments and promised a written order by Friday, November 20. She agreed Owen's failure to review a key laboratory report before testifying was a serious error, writing that it "undermines public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system". But she found it was not intentional bad faith, and the report was not discovered until November 2022, months after the indictments. The motion, filed August 10, 2026, was denied in full.

Background: A Case That Has Gripped America

The killings at Moselle, the Murdaugh family's hunting estate, became one of the most followed true-crime stories in the United States. Maggie and Paul Murdaugh were found shot dead at the property on the night of June 7, 2021. Alex Murdaugh first said he had found the bodies after visiting his ailing mother. Prosecutors later argued he killed them to hide a fraud in which he had stolen millions from clients and his own law firm.

The first trial, in Walterboro in early 2023, ended with guilty verdicts on two counts of murder and two counts of possessing a weapon during a violent crime. In May 2026, the South Carolina Supreme Court threw it out, ruling court clerk Rebecca Hill had improperly influenced the jury. Read our report on the November 13 hearing. Murdaugh remains in prison on separate financial-crime sentences.

Alex Murdaugh Retrial: What the Judge Decided

McCaslin's order turns on one distinction: the difference between a serious mistake and deliberate misconduct. A defendant claiming a misled grand jury must generally show bad faith and that the deception mattered. The judge found neither element satisfied. Owen's unreviewed report was a serious error, but one made without knowledge of it, discovered only after the indictments, could not have been a deliberate attempt to mislead the grand jury.

The ruling also settles a practical question. Prosecutors had been ready to seek fresh indictments on December 10 if the motion succeeded; that fallback is no longer needed. The four original charges — two counts of murder and two counts of possessing a weapon during a violent crime — remain in place as the July 2022 grand jury returned them.

Reactions and Quotes

The defence had argued the grand jury was given evidence about the blood spatter and the ammunition that prosecutors now accept did not exist as described. The judge's order acknowledged the force of that complaint, calling Owen's failure an error that "undermines public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system". The blunt language shows the court took the allegation seriously, even while rejecting the remedy the defence sought.

For the state, the ruling removes a major obstacle only months before trial. Prosecutors had argued the remaining evidence — the timeline of his movements that night, the forensic evidence, and his shifting accounts — was more than enough to support the indictments. McCaslin agreed, holding that "the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause". The state can now focus on the retrial.

Why It Matters

The decision matters beyond this case. The Murdaugh retrial is among the highest-profile criminal proceedings in the country, and every pretrial ruling is watched closely. A dismissal would have forced prosecutors to start over; instead, the ruling affirms the charges can stand on the undisputed evidence. Read how another high-profile jury reached its verdict this week in the Palisades Fire arson trial.

It also matters because of what the judge said about the investigation. McCaslin's words put a judicial criticism of the case on the record, even as she kept the charges alive. That finding will likely feature in the retrial, where the defence will attack the investigation's credibility. Both sides carry something into April: the state keeps its indictments, and the defence keeps a judge's words against the star investigator.

What Happens Next

The calendar is now fixed. Both sides must agree on a juror questionnaire by January 20, 2027, for potential Sumter County jurors. Expert witness lists are due by March 1, 2027. Jury selection and trial begin the week of April 5, 2027, with McCaslin presiding. The move to Sumter County is meant to give both sides a fairer jury pool.

Before then, expect further fights over what evidence the jury will hear, including the financial-crimes evidence from the first trial. Prosecutors used Murdaugh's thefts from clients to argue for a motive; the defence will try to limit that evidence the second time around. For now, the path is clear: the indictments stand and Murdaugh will face a second jury for the killings of Maggie and Paul Murdaugh. Read about another South Carolina case heard in Lexington this month.

Frequently Asked Questions

What did Judge McCaslin decide about Alex Murdaugh's charges?
She denied his motion to dismiss. All four July 2022 grand jury charges remain in place, and the retrial will proceed.

Why did Murdaugh's lawyers want the indictments thrown out?
They said SLED agent David Owen misled the grand jury about blood spatter and shotgun ammunition evidence.

When is the Alex Murdaugh retrial?
The retrial begins the week of April 5, 2027, in Sumter County before Judge Debra McCaslin. Questionnaire due January 20, 2027; expert lists by March 1, 2027.

Why was Murdaugh's first conviction overturned?
The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned the March 2023 convictions in May 2026 after finding court clerk Rebecca Hill improperly influenced jurors.

Is Alex Murdaugh in prison now?
Yes. He remains imprisoned on separate financial-crime sentences for fraud and money laundering.

US News Pulse
Written by
US News Pulse Newsroom
Editorial Team

The US News Pulse newsroom covers breaking news across the United States and the world, working from wire services, official statements and on-the-record sources. Every story is reviewed against our editorial standards before publication. Corrections and tips: info@usnewspulse.com

About our newsroom

Leave a Comment

  • Latest
  • Popular

Atlas de World Labs se abre a todos: convierte cualquier fot

1

Memorando secreto de Hegseth limita la defensa entre EE. UU.

2

Hinojosa Vows to Scrap Abbott's H-1B Hiring Freeze on Day On

3

Susan Smith Denied Parole a Second Time 32 Years After Drown

4

Senado de EE. UU. presenta proyecto de defensa de 1,1 billon

5

Trump expone la división de su gabinete sobre China por los

6

Trump deberá declarar ante la BBC antes del 22 de enero, ord

7

Susan Smith busca su libertad: segunda audiencia de libertad

8

Muere Miguel Ángel Félix Gallardo, fundador del cártel de Gu

9

Un barco con unos 100 migrantes naufraga frente a Senegal y

10

Trump Library Foundation Raised $57.6 Million in 2025, Filin

11

Arch Manning Stuns LSU With Last-Second TD as No. 6 Texas Wi

12

Paris Hilton and AOC Push DEFIANCE Act on Deepfakes at Capit

13

Wall Street Slides Again as Nasdaq Falls 2.5% in Third Strai

14

Permanent US Military Base in Poland Backed by Pentagon - US

15

NSA Outage Spreads to Georgia Intel Hub as Staff Locked Out

16

Jueza declara a ICE en desacato por volver a detener a inmig

17

Los Spurs vencen 110-102 a los Jazz con 31 puntos de Harper

18

Subtropical Storm Kyle Could Form Off East Coast, Snarl Than

19

Johnson Controls pagará $5 millones por fallas de cibersegur

20